Tag Archives: Africa

‘Turkishmaninacanstan’ Strikes Back

Readers of this blog know that from time to time, I have had to criticize those in the workers’ comp industry for their short-sightedness, narrow-mindedness, excessive American Exceptionalism, “Know-nothingism”,  xenophobia and subtle racism.

But when a well-respected online journal re-posts an article by the chief anti-medical travel opponent in the workers’ comp world, it is high time that the medical travel industry speak up and defend itself.

As a tireless advocate for medical travel in workers’ comp, I am leading the charge that you, my friends around the world must do for yourselves.

You will notice the title of this post. This is what the individual in question calls those countries that provide medical travel services. Also, please note that by using this canard as my title, I am in no way insulting Turkey, or any other nation that markets their medical care to the world.

There is fair criticism of Turkey and many other countries in the medical travel industry, but those criticisms are meant to improve the services and to correct the mistakes of the past, and not to pass judgement on them.

But when someone uses a term such as ‘Turkishmaninacanstan’, it conjures up the worse images of third world poverty and backwardness in all aspects of life of the nations so broadly brushed with that epithet.

The individual who coined that despicable name is a self-styled, right-wing American conservative who lives on the gulf coast of the state of Florida, a region where many individuals like him retire to after their careers have declined to play golf.

While this individual may not be one of those just yet, the fact that he dismisses new ideas, that he insults the millions of men and women around the world who are trying to offer real low cost medical care at equal or better quality, that he insults the very nations who could use those resources they are spending to bring medical travelers to their countries as a way to improve their balance of trade and economic power in the global economy, when they could be used to raise the living standards of their poorest citizens, is something that can no longer go unanswered.

So, I ask all of you, doctors, nurses, travel agents, medical tourism promoters and facilitators who are legitimately trying to provide better medical care at lower cost to all of the world’s citizens, to speak up and tell this individual and those like him, that your countries are not ‘Turkishmaninacanstans’, and that you are developing world-class medical facilities that outshine those in his own country, and mine.

Basically, he is calling you con artists and frauds, and that is something that only you can stop.

 

 

 

 

How Medical Tourism Hospitals are Developed

Image

Today’s second post is courtesy of Maria Todd, CEO of Mercury Healthcare International.

While her article is about hospital development in Africa, specifically the work she is doing in Nigeria, it is instructive on how hospital development in other regions of the world are laying the groundwork for the expansion of medical tourism.

In the article, she explains why Africa is targeted for financing and why now, how to size the facility and the market, what is different about hospital development and inpatient utlization in Africa, where the money comes from, the investment risk and capital funding in Africa, and some of the pitfalls that can happen when a company like hers is called in to help develop a hospital, and there is not much cash to be had, or as she puts it:

Apples and little green monkeys fall from trees – not cash

Being an expert in medical tourism and healthcare, Maria has made a name for herself, which is why she takes on such a daunting challenge as hospital development in Africa. Perhaps one day, Africa will be known as a shining example of medical tourism, and she and her company will have made it possible.

From Pariah to Player: South Africa’s Journey towards Becoming a Medical Tourism Destination

dbi_flag_southafrica

Six months ago, I was contacted by Greer van Zyl, a Health Communications Consultant specializing in public health, advocacy, and media relations, who is currently a Community of Practice Manager at the SBCC Centre of Excellence, Wits School of Public Health in Johannesburg, South Africa. She had found a copy of my White Paper on medical tourism and workers’ compensation, and wanted my permission to quote me in an article she was writing on the subject of medical tourism in South Africa.

Naturally, I was excited by the prospect of being in print in South Africa, as my White Paper had just recently been published online by the Medical Tourism Association (it has been removed over a copyright issue, but that’s another story).

Yesterday, Greer was kind enough to forward to me the link to the published article. She told me that due to word restraints, the original text she wrote was shortened, but it still conveys the meaning of what my original text was about. The article appears in the Health Professions Council of South Africa’s (HPCSA) The Bulletin. The article can be found on pages 28-29.

The article, entitled, Medical Tourism – SA’s Undiscovered Little Gem, introduces medical tourism as a relatively new concept in South Africa, and is regarded as an untapped sector for positioning the country as a destination of choice for medical procedures.

One area Greer discusses with regard to medical tourism is the high cost of medical care in the US and the impact that has on the workers’ compensation market here, as she quotes yours truly.

Medical tourists from America are likely to flock abroad as medical costs in the US drive patients to seek cheaper healthcare, particularly for workers’ compensation for injuries such as knee replacements, hip replacements and spinal fusions. These procedures cost considerably less in India, Thailand and Singapore. In Singapore, for example, the cost of knee replacement surgery, the airfare, and hospital and hotel accommodation can be six times lower than that in the US. A spinal fusion in Singapore costs up to 12 times less than in the US; in India, it costs 20 times less. Richard Krasner, a risk management consultant in Florida, US, says that this globalization of healthcare will require the removal of barriers to provide the best care possible at the lowest cost. “Healthcare cost savings through medical tourism can be just as beneficial in workers’ compensation.”

To compare with Greer’s original text, I am including the following:

Increasing medical costs in the US is likely to see a growth spurt as patients seek cheaper healthcare abroad. One untapped area is workers’ compensation for injuries such as knee replacement, hip replacement and spinal fusion. These cost considerably less in countries such as India, Thailand and Singapore, where a knee replacement, including airfare, hospital and hotel, can be six times lower than that of the US retail cost. A spinal fusion in Singapore is up to 12 times less than in the US, while in India the procedure costs 20 times less.

“Medical tourism is likely to experience explosive growth over the next three to five years due to changes in the US healthcare industry brought about by reform. This globalization of healthcare will require the removal of barriers to provide the best care possible at the lowest cost. Healthcare cost savings through medical tourism can be just as beneficial in workers’ compensation,” says Richard Krasner, a risk management consultant practicing in Florida.

To emphasize the importance of the development of medical tourism in South Africa, and it’s positioning as a medical tourism destination, one of the speakers at the 5th World Medical Tourism and Global Healthcare Congress I attended last October in Hollywood, Florida, was Dr. Gwendoline Ramokgopa, Deputy Minister of Health, in the National Department of Health of South Africa. Dr. Ramokgopa represented the highest level government official to attend the conference, and signals South Africa’s willingness to be a player in the emerging medical tourism industry.

Despite all the economic, political and social problems racking South Africa today, the fact that the country’s leaders and healthcare advocates are focusing on medical tourism is a good sign that South Africa can be a major factor in the growth of the industry, not only worldwide, but on the African continent itself. As more countries to South Africa’s north get into the market, and as South Africa is recognized as a “rising star”, the outlook for medical tourism in Africa is good.

My sincere thanks to Greer for her very good article.